Something happened on the way to the forum

Posted on Wednesday 5 April 2006

There are at least four schools of thought in Shariah, and if you go back to the ninth century (if you must, I wouldn’t go there), you will find that you were free to choose which Shariah you wanted to follow, if any. Something then happened on the way to the Forum.

-Mash, from an entry on his blog “-Or How I Learned to Stop Worrying

On a quest for something much different online this morning, I came across Mash, a moderate Muslim, and his interpretation of the Koran and Sharia law.

It’s a fascinating entry, and I recommend reading it all. He concludes with:

I hope you find the answers I’ve given to be satisfactory. I am sure I am not the only Muslim to have similar thoughts. When you look a little deeper into Islam, and beyond the caricatures and the Fanatics, you might find that the vast majority of practicing devout Muslims live a life of peace and tolerance. It may not fit the image of Islam some people want to see; it may not fit the Clash of Civilizations argument; but it reflects reality.

Polimom - and much of the Western World, I suspect - is immensely concerned with the point he makes here. Is it the vast majority? Does it reflect reality?

His take on his religion, in combination with a relevant article in today’s Washington Post about efforts in West Bengal (India) to overhaul the madrasas (Islamic religious schools), make for an interesting look at a side of Islam we aren’t seeing much of lately.

Two side notes:

  • Polimom had a friend years ago - an American woman - who was enamored of the Middle Eastern culture. She married a Muslim man and converted to Islam. I’ve never understood the attraction, personally, but she has given me many examples that sound similar to Mash’s interpretation, above.
  • In a recent blog entry, a commenter suggested that the Islam we’re dealing with in the Mid-East right now is comparable to Christianity 250 years ago. I replied that I thought he was off by several centuries. Mash puts the time capsule in the 9th Century. I think he’s right.

1 Comment for 'Something happened on the way to the forum'

  1.  
    April 5, 2006 | 1:05 pm
     

    I crossposted this article to Daily Kos . There is a very lively discussion going on there. I also welcome you to come to my site and leave a comment there.

    I anticipated that this post would stir debate and I am very glad to see that most of the debate has been very constructive and has moved the discussion forward.

Comments on this blog are subject to the guidelines stated in the Comments Policy.
First-time comments are held for moderator approval. Please use a valid email address.

Leave a comment

(required)

(required)


Information for comment users
Line and paragraph breaks are implemented automatically. Your e-mail address is never displayed. Please consider what you're posting.

Use the buttons below to customise your comment.


RSS feed for comments on this post | TrackBack URI